On April 23, 2015 a presidential decree dissolved the Sant’Anna e San Sebastiano hospital trust in Caserta because of infiltration and influence by organised crime. Five local or provincial health authorities had been dissolved in earlier years, but never a hospital. The dissolution came, the Italian Ministry of the Interior writes, after judicial proceedings involving the hospital’s administrative and medical leadership. The extraordinary commission that took it over replaced the administrative and medical directors and found a treasury service extended for years at excessive cost, suppliers paid late, and cash deposits with unexplained gaps for sums never banked. It examined contracts it called sensitive and sent its findings to the Public Prosecutor’s Office at the Court of Santa Maria Capua Vetere and to the regional prosecutor of the Court of Auditors. By the time its management ended, in 2017, supplier payment times had fallen below 50 days.
Four months after the hospital, on August 27, 2015, it was the turn of Municipio X of Rome, the first municipal district ever dissolved, with 229,642 inhabitants. In 2016 came Brescello, in the province of Reggio Emilia, the first municipality in Emilia-Romagna dissolved for mafia infiltration. In 2017, Lavagna in Liguria. The Minister of the Interior’s report on 2017, sent to Parliament in March 2018, makes it possible to follow this expansion, geographical and institutional, and to see what the commissioners found when they entered the offices.
The district of beaches
In Municipio X the commission of inquiry, according to the report, had found organised-crime interests in the local economy and above all in the management of state-owned coastal areas. It had examined procedures for awarding contracts and concessions on public land concluded in favour of firms linked, directly or indirectly, to members of what the report calls Mafia Capitale; the same methods had been found in contracts for tree pruning, cleaning, maintenance and the supervision of some beaches in 2014. The district had already been dissolved by order of the Mayor of Rome after its president resigned; the decree of August 27, 2015 placed it under an extraordinary commission for eighteen months.
The commission took office on September 9, 2015. It found offices scattered too widely across the territory, few senior managers and an understaffed municipal police force; it rotated staff, began recognising off-budget debts built up through constant use of emergency procedures without funding, and checked the tenders for bathing services on the stretches of beach open to the public. Its management ended in 2017, like that of the Caserta hospital.
The line moving north
The Ministry describes the geography of dissolutions as a growing trend in the north of the country. In 2016 Brescello, a town of 5,546 people, was the seventh municipal council dissolved in northern Italy; according to the published version, which cites the report on the previous two years, the earliest cases had been Bardonecchia, on May 2, 1995, Bordighera, on March 24, 2011, and Ventimiglia, on February 6, 2012. In 2017 the dissolution of Lavagna was followed by an inspection in a Lombard town, Seregno.
In Brescello the extraordinary commission also intervened in the foundation “Paese di Don Camillo e Peppone”, which runs the local tourism system: it created the post of auditor, replaced the outside consultants and introduced a budget forecast. The commission’s mandate, together with those in Mazzarrà Sant’Andrea, Nardodipace, Trentola Ducenta and Corleone, was extended so that the programmes under way could be completed.
The report’s explanation is explicit. Judicial investigations, it writes, have established the relocation and colonisation of the mafia and the invasive presence of organised crime in northern Italy, with a deep capacity to infiltrate, above all by the ‘ndrangheta, the legal economy of towns large and small. The methods found in northern authorities are the same seen elsewhere, and are concentrated in the sectors that attract criminal groups’ economic interests, starting with public contracts.
The centre of gravity, however, remains in the south. Of the 21 municipal councils dissolved in 2017, twelve were in Calabria, including Canolo on May 5 and Petronà on November 24; four in Campania, including Crispano on January 24, Scafati on January 27 and San Felice a Cancello on May 15; two in Apulia, including Parabita on February 17; two in Sicily, including Castelvetrano, with 31,834 inhabitants, on June 7. In 2017 there were 38 extraordinary commissions at work: 18 in Calabrian towns, 7 in Campania, 6 in Sicily, 3 in Apulia, 1 in Liguria, 1 in Emilia, plus the Caserta hospital and the Rome district. In 2015, according to the figures in the published version, seven councils had been dissolved.
Budgets in the red
The figure that links the cases is financial. In 2017, 9.5% of the municipalities dissolved for mafia influence or infiltration had declared insolvency or were under multi-year financial rebalancing; out of Italy’s 7,960 municipalities, the share was 0.9%. According to the report, the commissions of inquiry found in several cases imbalances due, at least in part, to anomalies and irregularities in taxation and collection: revenue never received. And insolvency has a cost that falls on residents, because it forces local tax rates and charges to the maximum.
Lavagna, dissolved by decree on March 27, 2017, shows how this works. The town is among those that turned to the multi-year financial rebalancing procedure, and its extraordinary commission lists, among the steps to improve the accounts, raising the municipal IRPEF surcharge to the maximum, increasing the IMU rate and introducing a tourist tax. The same commission reorganised waste collection, a service whose running, the report says, was one of the grounds for dissolving the council, extending door-to-door collection to new parts of the town.
Read this way, the report suggests that scrutiny of a town’s finances is also an early indicator of vulnerability. That is our inference, not a statement by the Ministry: the data show that insolvency and dissolution often go together, not which comes first.
When judges annul and then think again
Dissolution can be challenged in court, and the litigation does not always go one way. In Giardinello, in the province of Palermo, a first-instance court had annulled the decree, and from March 24, 2015 the elected bodies had returned to office; on October 9, 2015, after the Council of State upheld the appeal against that judgment, the extraordinary commission was reinstated. The same happened in Tropea, where the commission returned on September 27, 2017.
In 2017, according to the report, all 8 rulings on the lawfulness of dissolutions, 5 by the Council of State and 3 by the Lazio administrative court, went in favour of the administration. The Council of State reaffirmed the preventive nature of the measure, already stated, as the published version recalls, in Third Section judgment no. 5023 of November 30, 2015. And it set two criteria that explain why these appeals are hard to win. First: the fact that a town lies in an area where crime is entrenched is not enough on its own, since being located in such a context is not in itself proof that its officials colluded with crime, though it can count when accompanied by other circumstances. Second: the prefect’s report need not account for the authority’s lawful acts, because, the judges write, if some window-dressing were enough to lessen the risk of dissolution, it would be all too easy to resort to it (Council of State, no. 4578/2017).
Finally there is the relationship between elected members and the bureaucracy. Even when it is the offices that have been penetrated, responsibility can go back to the political bodies: under Article 107 of the consolidated law they retain the tasks of direction and oversight, which must cover the work of senior officials across the board. For the Council of State, failure to take steps to restore legality is part of the institutional responsibility of the authority’s political bodies.
The evidence file
- Document read: Italian Ministry of the Interior, Department for Internal and Territorial Affairs, report of the Minister of the Interior on the work of the extraordinary commissions running authorities dissolved for mafia infiltration and influence, year 2017, March 2018 (full text, in Italian).
- Document cited but not re-read: the Minister’s report on 2015-2016, from which the published version takes the seven dissolutions of 2015, the precedents of Bardonecchia, Bordighera and Ventimiglia and Council of State judgment no. 5023/2015.
- Cases: Sant’Anna e San Sebastiano hospital trust, Caserta (decree of April 23, 2015); Municipio X of Rome (decree of August 27, 2015); Brescello (2016); Lavagna (2017); inspection in Seregno (2017); commissions reinstated in Giardinello (October 9, 2015) and Tropea (September 27, 2017).
- Data: 21 councils dissolved and 38 commissions at work in 2017; 9.5% of dissolved towns insolvent or rebalancing against 0.9% nationally; 8 administrative rulings in 2017, all in favour of the administration.
- Personal data: no official, manager or business owner is named; the firms in Municipio X are described only as the report describes them.
- Basis for reproduction: Article 5 of Italian Law no. 633 of April 22, 1941, which excludes official acts of the State and public administrations from copyright.

